Movie review: Civil War (2024)

What is so disappointing about Alex Garland’s Civil War is that it completely misses the point about war photography. Garland had an opportunity to really explore how photography can create huge cultural touchstones that amplify the impact of, often relatively small, real-world events. This is why war photographers put themselves at risk – to portray meaning. And Garland decides to make a story devoid of meaning.

There are so many examples of well known war photography that has contributed to our culture, but one stands out to me.

Continue reading “Movie review: Civil War (2024)”

Hi! We’re the IDF

We’ve been committing war crimes and atrocities for several generations

There’s no Palestinian too small or innocent to have their limbs blown off or their family wiped out in a targeted strike

We restrict aid, electricity and water to some of the most vulnerable little humans on the planet

We massacre civilians who we’ve just told to evacuate their homes

We execute prisoners in the open, and we don’t stop there – we’ve even done it in hospitals!

You might say hospitals are our specialty. Where there’s a child being treated for third degree burns, there’s an Israeli missile headed to kill her doctor.

Journalists aren’t safe either – and they don’t even have to be within Israeli or Palestinian territories to be targeted! We often lie about targeting journalists, and the West believes us, bless them

Humanitarian experts and historians around the world describe what we’re doing as genocide! But did the Nazis ever warn people in their death camps that they were about to be gassed? We think not. Morale high ground secured.

Continue reading “Hi! We’re the IDF”

Fuck Prince Philip

Fuck Prince Philip.

One day of mourning and sycophancy was pathetic enough, but this is now a full-on national tantrum.

I guess we’re seeing the death throes of the remaining few generations who are still brainwashed by the cartel of the monarchy.

Philip was a racist bastard, part of a eugenicist regime built on a tower of black and brown bodies, empowered by a propaganda machine so powerful it can bring our entire system of government to a halt so politicians can violently proselytise at each other for hours in the heart of our democratic chambers about the Dear Great Leader and how noble it is to sacrifice your life upholding those most British values of colonialism, blood purity, and service to the state.

North Korea *wishes* it had subjects as obedient as ours.

But Philip’s generations of worshippers and disciples are dying, now faster than ever. They should consider themselves lucky that the end of their beloved monarchy will be with a whimper.

(Credit to Ash Sarkar for the phrase “cartel” in reference to the monarchy)

Stokely Carmichael and White Fragility

TW: this may not be comfortable reading for Black people, as I am sharing my own anti-racist education, and therefore my ignorance.

I’ve just learned about Stokely Carmichael, a huge figure in the US and global civil rights movement, who transitioned from a mostly non-violent philosophy to a much more radical one. As chairman of the SNCC he stopped white membership, and soon after gave a speech during which he popularised the phrase “Black Power,” triggering a new radical movement in civil rights.

This is really profound for us white people to pay attention to, right now – when even the most ‘well-meaning’ of us can have our white fragility triggered by the most genuine and important cries for freedom. Imagine the bravery of Carmichael in revoking white membership to the SNCC, anticipating the backlash of white fragility it would cause – while still knowing this was needed for radical change.

So I will try to pay more attention to the kinds of white fragility I see in myself and others, and know that real radical change requires the provocation of white fragility. I must deeply acknowledge that white people are all complicit in white supremacy, and we can not be a part of radical change without accepting our inherent role in maintaining white supremacy.

https://www.history.com/topics/black-history/stokely-carmichael

Replaying war crimes on a film set

I’ve read a lot about the Vietnam/American War, both nonfiction and fiction. It was this conflict in particular that helped me finally grok the immense failure of sentience at the heart of warfare, and the horrors of capitalist and colonialist conflicts.

In Vietnam, class, race and culture collided in the context of a truly hellish war, exposing the hypocrisy of Western society through the blood of millions of young Americans and Vietnamese.

Obviously that conflict changed our world in many ways. I don’t think its profundity can be overstated.

Continue reading “Replaying war crimes on a film set”

Is Buddhism Sexist?

The short answer is yes. Buddhism has always been sexist.

But the core principles of Buddhism should prevent sexism or any kind of judgement based on forms and appearances. So are there just a bunch of people doing Buddhism really badly?

In Florence Caplow and Susan Moon’s carefully curated selection of Zen koans, The Hidden Lamp, Rita M Gross concisely outlines the prevalence of sexism and misogyny in traditional and contemporary Buddhism:

Vajrayana Buddhists in Tibet also believe, in common with many Asian Buddhists, that it is impossible to attain full enlightenment in a woman’s body and that being born female is unfortunate. That tells us a lot about what women have had to go through!

Continue reading “Is Buddhism Sexist?”

Why my incel pal still owes $1000 to charity

Content warning: lots of misogyny, sexual assault, racism, violence.

I have spent quite a lot of time engaging with incels (“involuntary celibates”) on Reddit in the past. Their highly misogynistic, often racist, and downright petulant worldview is a perfect storm of wilful ignorance, blind hatred, and childlike tantrum-throwing.

Incels, for those who don’t know, are a disparate community of women-haters who believe that women are both worthless objects and also the most important things in the universe. Incels believe that all men deserve love and affection from the women who they find most attractive, and that the best way of going about receiving that affection is to rape and murder them.

Although incels deserve nothing more than total ignominy and dismissal, I was fascinated by the blind rage and pig-headedness of the average incel opinion I saw floating around on Reddit. I eventually started talking to a few in private messages, trying to learn about their lives and offering a compassionate response, letting them know that there was a way out of their destructive ways of thinking (Yes, I know – misguided and maybe plain wrong, but I wanted to try).

Continue reading “Why my incel pal still owes $1000 to charity”

Remembering the Tiananmen Massacre

Thirty years ago today, the 1989 Democracy Movement in Beijing reached its end. Using tanks and bullets, the Chinese government massacred as many as 10,000 peaceful student protestors in Tiananmen square and across Beijing over several days in early June.

Students who feared the direction of the authoritarian Chinese state had spent several weeks camped out in Tiananmen square, at the centre of Beijing, demanding freedom of the press and accountability for government officials. Protests spread across the city, until in early June the government mobilised thousands of troops from all over China and marched towards the square – a process lasting several days and costing many lives.

Although protestors had managed to slow the advance of the troops, and in some cases had convinced soldiers to lay down their weapons, the military reached the square in the early morning of the 4th of June. Hundreds of students had already been slaughtered.

Continue reading “Remembering the Tiananmen Massacre”

Why right- and left-wing views are not equally valid moralities

This will be short and is purely my opinion. You have been warned.

A line I’ve often heard in discussions about right- and left-wing views is that both perspectives are grounded in social benefits.

This line holds that right-wing views are about ‘protecting the group’ – the right-leaning morality is about keeping our family safe. It defends us from outside threats.

Meanwhile, left-wing views are about ‘protecting the outsider’ – the left-leaning morality is about opening our arms, lowering our defences, and treating those less fortunate like human beings rather than burdens or obstacles.

So this right/left dichotomy is framed as a necessary balance between building stable, safe, happy groups and opening those groups to outsiders.

The problem is that this interpretation of right-wing morality assumes a bunch of stuff.

Continue reading “Why right- and left-wing views are not equally valid moralities”

Bigotry requires being an utter dolt, unsurprisingly

Iain M Banks. His writing could vary from the bitterly poetic – such as the story of the passionate and tragic sexual relationship between an aristocrat brother and sister (A Song of Stone); to the purely silly – such as the alien humanoid who medically enhances his body to be covered in functional penises (The Hydrogen Sonata).

Yes, say what you will about Banks; but he certainly didn’t like to limit himself.

Despite the range of his imagination, one concurrent theme throughout all Banks’ science fiction novels – and in much of his ‘mainstream’ fiction – was egalitarianism.

OT09y39

Continue reading “Bigotry requires being an utter dolt, unsurprisingly”